Iron Fitting – Iron Out The Details
Since the vast majority of golfers’ full complement of “irons” should include a mix of hybrids and irons, here are a number of other important elements of iron set fitting that can help ensure golfers are custom fit for the best overall iron set.
Iron Lengths and Length Increments
The starting length of the combined hybrid/iron set starts with a measurement of the distance from the golfer’s wrist to the floor. The measurement is then compared to a chart that lists the initial length of the irons for each different W to F measurement. The final length is then a process of swing evaluation to determine if the initial length recommendation should be altered slightly longer or shorter based on the golfer’s posture, flexibility and comfort over the ball and through impact.
Once the final iron length is determined, there is no rule that says all the irons have to be made in the usual half-inch increments seen on the vast majority of irons sold off the shelf. Most golfers who measure for longer length irons can find much better iron consistency and maintain the most consistent swing posture when the iron length increments are altered to 3/8”. With 3/8” or even 5/16” increments between the irons, the higher number irons progressively become longer in relation to what they would be in a set made with normal half-inch increments. This can deliver a much higher level of comfort over the ball and through impact with the high number irons and wedges.
Iron Shaft Fitting
Golfers of average to below average strength or golfers with a smoother swing tempo who have always played heavier weight steel iron shafts (100-130g) can find more comfort as well as a few more yards in distance by switching to a much lighter weight graphite iron shaft (55-85g). Measuring the golfer’s swing speed and observing their downswing force and point of wrist cock release allows the golfer to find the best performing shaft flex and bend profile (distribution of stiffness) in the shafts.
Iron Swingweight or MOI (Iron to Iron Swing Feel Matching)
All golfers need to find the right headweight feel to match to their sense of swing timing, rhythm and tempo to be able to achieve the highest level of on-center hit consistency. But let me clue you into a totally valid replacement for conventional swingweight matching that has proven to be a better way to make all the clubs swing with the same feel and effort – MOI Matching.
Unlike swingweight matching, making the irons to each have the same Moment of Inertia will make each club so it requires the same effort to swing. If you’d like to experience what MOI matching can do for your or any golfer’s shot consistency, use lead tape to make your irons follow a progressive, half-swingweight point increase per club down through the set. Interested golfers and clubmakers can read more about MOI matching as a replacement for swingweight matching.
Iron Lie Fitting
What more can be said? Every golfer must have the lie angles of their irons dynamically fit and adjusted to ensure the centre of the sole is the point of contact with the ground. Not static lie fitting, but dynamic lie fitting so every variable from the swing is accommodated to ensure the proper lie angle for each iron. Failure to do so is a ticket to missing more greens.
There are two different accepted methods of dynamically fitting the lie angle of the irons, hitting shots from a lie board to note the point of impact on the sole with the board, and the ink line on the back of the ball method. Of the two, the ink line on the back of the ball is being recognized as more reliable and accurate. This method involves putting a thick line on the ball with a Sharpie pen, positioning the ball with the line vertical and facing the clubface, then looking at the angle of the ink line transferred to the clubface to note the proper lie adjustment. With a properly fit lie, the ink line will be vertical on the clubface. A lie that is too upright for the golfer will be revealed by the ink line being angled toward the toe. When the lie is too flat the ink line will be angled toward the heel.
Overall, the proper custom Iron fitting analysis can make a big difference for golfers and can bring about more greens hit in regulation as well as a lower score.
Tom
Hi Tom, I was wondering if you could clarify something for me. If I am currently 1” over standard in my irons with no change in lie angle. I struggle with my long irons but do not want to change to hybrids due to the fact I play my golf in Scotland on Links courses. Theoretically could I actually drop down to 1/2 “ over standard and physically bend them 2 degrees upright in the hope of hit my longer irons more consistently, and then drop length in 3/8 increments? Can I just say thank you for sharing your knowledge.… Read more »
Hey Scott Thanks for stopping by to ask for a little help. And thanks so much for having discovered the books and your interest in this side of the game! I hope when you get the chance to read the Capn book that you enjoy it – there are a few of the stories in part 1 of that book that took place in Scotland so I do have great memories of your country. OK, on to the equipment stuff. You did not say why you struggle with the long irons. You also give the impression that you feel a… Read more »
Tom, thank you so much for the reply. I’ll be getting my copy of the new book shortly and cant wait to read it. With regard to the above, my main struggle is as you stated – hitting the long irons consistently. Having reread your book countless times, one of the many great takeaways that always sticks is to put the player in the longest length he can control and hit solid on centre the highest percentage of the time. At 6ft 3 inches with a wrist to floor of 39.5 I believe you may put me in a 5… Read more »
Scott Many thanks for the additional information! I doubt very seriously that you would see much of a consistency difference from shortening the irons just a half inch. That’s not very much and while some players might detect some difference, most would not for a change of only half an inch. Based on my experience, a 39.5 WTF for someone who is 6’3 is certainly not impossible but it is a little long for what I am used to seeing. So you may want to check that carefully using these guidelines for the measurement – stand comfortably erect, shoulders perfectly… Read more »
Hi Tom, loved the new book, thanks for my signed copy. Question, the line on the back of the ball is the best method for establishing correct lie. I agree, and is the one i use too, but, in Cap n Clubmaker, you say the lie board method is less accurate for a number of reasons. You stated one as being the thick soles in the toe area of an iron if i remember correctly. If you have time, id love to know the other reasons, and why they make the test less accurate? I have an argument with a… Read more »
Chris Yes the big reason lie boards are not as accurate is because most irons have a sole width that is wider in the toe area than the heel so this puts the point of contact on the trailing edge for a properly fit lie more toward the toe side. Other reason is the golfer – it is very common to see golfers be uncomfortable with hitting balls off a hard surface that makes a noise and offers a jarring feeling when the sole hits the board. This can cause the golfer to flinch or otherwise adopt a position coming… Read more »
Hi Tom,
Would you be able to share your company’s standard steel iron shaft lengths? I’m finding very many different tables of the lengths around the internet and the one that seems to be the most consistent is the 1980’s standard where a 4-iron is 48″ and the PW/GW/SW/LW are all 35″.
In tempted to go with that as I have read your opinion on golfwrx about how 90% of golfers should play with shorter clubs. In not a club fitter, just a 22 handicapper looking to regrip and maybe shorten my current clubs..
Thanks,
Jeremy
JEREMY We look at the world of golf equipment from a pure fitting standpoint only so we don’t really set standards per se. But if we were to subscribe to a standard for iron lengths, they would be based on a 38″ #5 iron for men with half inch increments between each iron up and down. Lofts wise, that very much so is all over the map these days. I think what would help you more in this respect would be to refer to what would be AVERAGES in the industry for iron lofts among all the different iron models… Read more »
Tom I have just finished a Golfsmith course on club making in Cambridge England, but i was not over impressed with their tools, could you give me some insite into the best (for the price) Frequency machine, loft & lie machine, digital swingweight machine also do you use a specific machine when putting grip on like a laser altignment tool or do you do it by eye they also stated that when removing them by air, it stretched the grip? Last thing whet is the difference between using a spine machine (bearings) and a PURE machine Thanks in antisipation Ian… Read more »
IAN: Our company chooses not to offer clubmaking tools and machinery because the majority of our clubmaker customers are more experienced so they pretty much already have most of the tools and machines they need. One thing about selling clubmaking tools and machines is that the clubmakers buy these things one time – they don’t wear out. So if you want to keep selling tools and machines you need to keep finding new clubmakers. I’m a little out of the loop on the tools and machines Golfsmith sells. I always thought they sold what the USA GOlfsmith sent them to… Read more »